Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill initiated a lawsuit against 32 entities representing 13 prediction market brands last week. The legal action was promptly followed by a temporary restraining order issued by Judge Jeffrey Johnson.
What Happened
Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill filed a lawsuit last week against 32 entities associated with 13 prediction market brands, including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, and Coinbase, among others. Hours after the lawsuit was filed, Judge Jeffrey Johnson of the 21st Judicial District Court in Tangipahoa Parish issued an ex parte temporary restraining order. This order prohibits the defendants from offering or facilitating event contracts for Louisiana customers without state gaming authorization, mandates geofencing for Louisiana customers, and bars them from claiming their products are authorized in the state, according to Legal Sports Report.
Following this, some of the implicated operators and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) have challenged the order. Kalshi filed a preemptive federal lawsuit on October 23, arguing federal jurisdiction over its federally designated contract market operations. Kalshi later withdrew its request for a temporary restraining order but maintained its request for a preliminary injunction in its existing federal case. Louisiana’s response is due November 18, with Kalshi’s reply due November 20, and a hearing scheduled for November 23. Separately, Polymarket’s US operator, QCX LLC, also filed a preemptive lawsuit on October 27, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief on similar grounds of federal regulation preemption.
Polymarket US subsequently moved Louisiana’s enforcement case to federal court on Friday, transferring it from Tangipahoa Parish to the Eastern District of Louisiana. The restraining order remains in effect unless a federal court dissolves or modifies it. Louisiana responded on Monday with an emergency motion to return the case to state court. Robinhood and Rothera Exchange and Clearing filed separate motions on Saturday to lift or narrow the restrictions of the restraining order, requesting expedited hearings. They argue that Louisiana lacks authority to regulate their federally supervised derivatives products and that the order is overly broad. The United States and the CFTC also filed their own lawsuit against Louisiana on Friday, seeking a declaration that Louisiana’s gambling laws are preempted by the federal Commodity Exchange Act when applied to event contracts traded on CFTC-regulated exchanges, as reported by Legal Sports Report.
Key Details
- Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill sued 32 entities linked to 13 prediction market brands last week, leading to a temporary restraining order, according to Legal Sports Report.
- Kalshi filed a preemptive federal lawsuit on October 23, arguing federal jurisdiction, and has maintained a request for a preliminary injunction.
- Polymarket’s US operator, QCX LLC, also filed a preemptive lawsuit on October 27 and moved Louisiana’s enforcement case to federal court, although the state’s restraining order remains active.
- The CFTC and the United States government filed a lawsuit against Louisiana on Friday, November 13, seeking to declare Louisiana’s gambling laws preempted by federal law for CFTC-regulated exchanges and requesting preliminary and permanent injunctive relief.
- Motions to intervene in the litigation were filed by two groups, including Underdog Prediction entities, North American Derivatives Exchange, Crypto.com entities, and associated Foris companies.
Why It Matters
The ongoing litigation between Louisiana, prediction market operators, and federal regulators establishes a precedent for the jurisdiction over event contracts. Louisiana asserts that these products constitute gambling and require state licensing, subjecting them to state sports betting laws. Conversely, prediction market operators and the federal government, including the CFTC, contend that these products are derivatives traded on federally regulated exchanges, placing them under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commodity Exchange Act and the CFTC.
This dispute could influence the regulation of the prediction market industry nationwide, defining the extent to which states can regulate event contracts on federally regulated exchanges. The Coalition for Prediction Markets has challenged comparisons with traditional gambling products, emphasizing that derivatives markets differ from sportsbooks. The resolution of these cases may clarify the regulatory framework for financial innovation in regulated markets.
What’s Next
Louisiana’s response to Kalshi’s preliminary injunction request is due on November 18, with Kalshi’s reply due November 20. A hearing for this matter is scheduled for November 23. Louisiana has also filed an emergency motion to return Polymarket’s case to state court, and has asked Judge Africk to either pause the federal government’s lawsuit or grant more time to respond to its motion for emergency relief. Robinhood and Rothera Exchange and Clearing have requested expedited hearings on their motions to lift or narrow the restraining order.
Sources & References
Main source
- Legal Sports Reportwww.legalsportsreport.com/287560/louisiana-prediction-market-battle-ramps-up-as-operators-cftc-strike-quickly/ from Legal Sports Report (opens in a new tab)legalsportsreport.com
Source published: