A federal appeals court has delivered a significant setback to prediction market operator Kalshi in its legal battle with Maryland regulators, ruling that the company failed to demonstrate that federal commodities law pre-empts the state’s authority to enforce its sports betting regulations. The 2-1 decision from the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on Tuesday upheld an earlier refusal to block state action against Kalshi, although the three judges were split on the reasoning behind their conclusions.
What Happened
The dispute originated in April 2025 when Maryland issued a cease-and-desist letter to Kalshi, asserting that the operator was offering sports wagering without the necessary state license. Kalshi subsequently challenged this, arguing that its sports event contracts are regulated under federal commodities law, thus pre-empting state gambling regulations. While similar arguments have found traction in some jurisdictions like New Jersey, the Fourth Circuit reached a different conclusion. The two judges in the majority issued separate concurring opinions against Kalshi, while the third judge filed a lengthy dissent supporting the operator’s position.
Key Details
- Majority Rules Against Kalshi: The Fourth Circuit voted 2-1, affirming an earlier decision that refused to block Maryland’s action against Kalshi.
- Judge Gregory’s Reasoning: The leading opinion, penned by Judge Roger Gregory, concluded that even if Kalshi’s contracts qualify as ‘swaps’ under the Commodity Exchange Act, Congress did not clearly intend to remove Maryland’s traditional authority to regulate gambling. Gregory stressed that gambling regulation has historically been a state responsibility and that courts should be reluctant to assume federal pre-emption without unmistakably clear congressional intent.
- No Conflict with Federal Law: Gregory also rejected Kalshi’s argument that Maryland’s licensing requirements conflict with federal law, finding that the state is not regulating derivatives markets generally but rather requiring entities offering sports wagering to comply with state licensing, advertising, and consumer protection rules. He posited that Kalshi can comply with both federal commodities regulation and Maryland’s gambling requirements simultaneously.
- Judge Thacker’s Analysis: In a separate concurring opinion, Judge Stephanie Thacker directly addressed whether Kalshi’s products qualify as ‘swaps’ under the Commodity Exchange Act. She concluded that they do not, stating that their payouts depend on the *outcome* of sporting events rather than merely the *occurrence* of those events, distinguishing them from traditional swaps.
- Split Reasoning: The court’s decision was notable for the lack of a unified majority opinion on the legal rationale, with two separate concurring opinions leading to the outcome and a dissenting judge backing Kalshi.
Why It Matters
This ruling is a significant victory for Maryland regulators and potentially sets a precedent for how federal commodities law intersects with state gambling regulations, particularly for novel prediction market products. Unlike courts in some other states, the Fourth Circuit has affirmed the strength of state authority in regulating gambling, even when financial instruments might arguably fall under federal commodities definitions. The divergent reasoning among the judges highlights the complex and evolving legal landscape surrounding prediction markets and their classification.
Imported source
- iGaming TodayMaryland Defeats Kalshi Appeal as Judges Split on Key Legal Questions (opens in a new tab)igamingtoday.com
Source published: