Kalshi Faces New York Restraining Order as Federal Intervention Fails

Automated news

A New York state judge is set to hear a request for a temporary restraining order against prediction market Kalshi, after federal efforts to intervene were denied. The New York Attorney General seeks to prevent Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a state license.

What Happened

The Trump administration unsuccessfully attempted to intervene after attorneys for the prediction market Kalshi warned that a temporary restraining order (TRO) sought by the New York State Attorney General could significantly disrupt its platform, as reported by Abcnews.com. New York Attorney General Letitia James requested the TRO after U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick denied Kalshi’s bid to move James’ lawsuit from state court to federal court on Friday, November 20, 2026. Judge Broderick ruled that prediction markets do not inherently fall outside state jurisdiction.

The Attorney General’s office then asked New York Judge Melissa Crane to issue the restraining order to prevent Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. Kalshi’s attorney, Sean Murphy, stated to Judge Crane that such an order would likely necessitate the liquidation of all open positions, potentially affecting markets beyond New York state. In response, Andrew Weisberg, an attorney for Kalshi’s regulator, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), urged another federal judge, Lorna Schofield, to block Judge Crane from ruling on the TRO request during an emergency telephone hearing on Friday. Weisberg argued that a complete shutdown of Kalshi’s nationwide operations would constitute irreparable harm to one of their regulated markets.

However, Kate Rhodes Janofsky, representing the New York Attorney General’s office, contended there was no basis for federal intervention given the scheduled state court hearing. Janofsky asserted that evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption had not been presented. Judge Schofield concurred, denying the application and declining to become involved in the matter. Judge Crane has scheduled a hearing on the TRO request for Monday.

Key Details

  • New York Attorney General Letitia James is seeking a temporary restraining order against Kalshi to halt the offering of sports contracts without a state license, according to Abcnews.com.
  • On Friday, November 20, 2026, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick denied Kalshi’s request to transfer the lawsuit from New York state court to federal court, ruling prediction markets are not necessarily beyond state jurisdiction (Abcnews.com).
  • Kalshi’s attorney, Sean Murphy, argued that the TRO would likely force the liquidation of open positions and disrupt markets beyond New York (Abcnews.com).
  • An attempt by the Trump administration to prevent a state judge from ruling on the TRO was denied by federal judge Lorna Schofield (Abcnews.com).
  • New York Judge Melissa Crane has scheduled a hearing on the TRO request for Monday, November 23, 2026 (Abcnews.com).

Why It Matters

This legal action by the New York Attorney General underscores ongoing regulatory scrutiny of prediction markets, particularly concerning licensing and the classification of their offerings. The denial of federal intervention by both Judge Broderick and Judge Schofield reinforces the potential for state-level jurisdiction over such platforms, even those regulated by federal bodies like the CFTC. The outcome of the restraining order hearing could impact Kalshi’s operational model within New York and potentially set precedents for how other states approach the regulation of prediction markets, especially regarding sports-related contracts. If granted, the TRO could force significant operational changes for Kalshi, including the liquidation of existing positions, which its attorney stated would disrupt markets.

What’s Next

New York Judge Melissa Crane has scheduled a hearing on the temporary restraining order request for Monday (Abcnews.com).

Sources & References

Main source

Additional references